One thing I will say about the Hurts situation, it did feel like the pressure got to him. It is hard to overlook that the worst game of the year for him came on the biggest stage. I don't know where Daboll lies in all of that, but if the guy calling the plays doesn't want you to be running the offense, and the guys catching the balls don't want you to be the one throwing it to them, that has to be a tremendous weight.
For me it was never about who the better quarterback was, I simply had faith Alabama could win with Hurts. But, I watched that crumble and even I had to concede something had to change at halftime. On the other hand, it doesn't seem like Daboll or some of those other guys really cared who was more prone to making mistakes, or what ever, they just wanted the more talented passer on the field. I just find it hard to figure out where the line lies really in terms of what should have happened and what actually happened. Hurts could have done better, but I doubt he was the only one.
Having said all of that, what's done is done. Tua got a chance to prove himself and while I think we all saw why rushing him out there earlier might not have worked, things should only get easier for him. But, with 3 years of eligibility left I find it hard to imagine Hurts is done as a QB. If I'm speaking not as an Alabama fan, but with more objectivity, the best thing for him if he wants to be a pocket passer is find a low pressure environment where he can sit for a year (learning) and then go out there and play. He really couldn't find a tougher position, with a backup like Tua, and the amount of pressure he had on his shoulders. He's younger than Tua, there is nothing at all to say that he can't progress and fix some issues over the next three seasons.