You continue to refer to Haynes, but he had a bad year last year other than a couple of long runs vs G5 teams. It’s like his heart wasn’t in it. I’m not sure. IMO, the med stats don’t tell the whole story: There were points in games where on a 3rd and short conversion, he could have easily made it with minimal effort and he failed. He was bad on pass pro. It was better that he move on because it was like he already had in his heart - maybe he was hurt, idk.
Btw, I was a big JH fan and felt he was under used in ‘23. I thought he would be a great fit in DeBoer’s system but I was wrong or he just didn’t want to be here any longer. I don’t blame him. Saban was gone and tho CKD’s culture seems to be player friendly, it may not be what JH was comfortable with. All of that is fine but I would not use him as an example. Something wasn’t right.
IMO, it may be year 5 before we know what DeBoer’s system really looks like because of the change in OL types.
You keep referring to too much being required of the QB. IMO, that’s not going to be a problem. Look what they’ve done with Ty who they did not recruit. He has some limitations that their guys won’t have. Even his training was under others. Look at the QB recruits they have brought in and are bringing in. I.e., they can evaluate and develop with the best - they may be the best.
Just a general comment not directed towards you: IMO, DeBoer is a very smart man and he’s only in his 4th year at the P4 level and look what he has accomplished. This, even though he inherited 2 good situations, including some real hurdles, it’s really amazing. 46-9, 1 conf champ, 1 NC game, playing for another conf champ, good chance to make another playoff. Has not had time to fully implement his system in either place. Appears to have created a welcoming culture and mentally tough attitude. No talk of anxiety. Was ahead of the curve re: a GM. Creating a player lead program. He inhabits a complicated world and he, like all, is flawed but the outlook is good. Many don’t care, but he is also a great guy.