Keelon Russell A-Day Film Study by JD Pickell - Me? I see Tua Flashbacks???

BamaMoon

Hall of Fame
Apr 1, 2004
24,574
24,439
282
Boone, NC
This is a good film review. Pickell thinks he'll be the starter.

But one of the reasons I posted this is because of the 3rd play Pickell highlights. It's a simple, quick slant near the goal line for a TD. The last time I remember a Bama QB hitting a slant and making it look so easy goes back to a former Bama QB you probably remember by the name of Tua!

 
This is a good film review. Pickell thinks he'll be the starter.

But one of the reasons I posted this is because of the 3rd play Pickell highlights. It's a simple, quick slant near the goal line for a TD. The last time I remember a Bama QB hitting a slant and making it look so easy goes back to a former Bama QB you probably remember by the name of Tua!

Hope he's more durable than Tua...
 
Hope he's more durable than Tua...
Totally different body type, but I was just referring to ease and accuracy of the throw. Nobody threw the slant like Tua! But this one reminded me of him!

Russell is slender, but this video also highlights his footwork. For a young player, it's elite. Hopefully it keeps him out of some trouble and bad hits! He is also very quick. Not sure about his speed but he moves very quickly...including his lightning fast release. Maybe the fastest we've seen at Bama?

Tua, love him to death, but he never knew when to give up on a play!
 
I wish we could have seen Mack at 100% at A-Day. That little injury affected him, and he had to leave the game early. CKD has said Mack is light years better than last year. And has been consistent in making plays. If the OL is underperforming, then Russell may the guy for his scrambling ability. But don't count Mack out just yet.
 
Totally different body type, but I was just referring to ease and accuracy of the throw. Nobody threw the slant like Tua! But this one reminded me of him!

Russell is slender, but this video also highlights his footwork. For a young player, it's elite. Hopefully it keeps him out of some trouble and bad hits! He is also very quick. Not sure about his speed but he moves very quickly...including his lightning fast release. Maybe the fastest we've seen at Bama?

Tua, love him to death, but he never knew when to give up on a play!
Yeah I wasn't being critical. It was almost always artwork when watching Tua throw the ball. It was then, and remains so, a shame that his body couldn't hold up.
 
I wish we could have seen Mack at 100% at A-Day. That little injury affected him, and he had to leave the game early. CKD has said Mack is light years better than last year. And has been consistent in making plays. If the OL is underperforming, then Russell may the guy for his scrambling ability. But don't count Mack out just yet.
I think the balanced view is that the competition will go into the fall. The fans won't pick the QB, but now the fans have seen with their own eyes how special Russell is. It was bad luck for Mack to get injured when he did, no doubt.

It may be the case that we have two very high level QBs, which is what the staff has been saying all along. Mack had a couple of brilliant throws, despite the slower day.

But as good 'ole Lou Holtz (RIP) once said, "If you have two quarterbacks, you don't have one."

Unless the momentum drastically changes, I think Mack just may be the unlucky one of having KR as his main competition. The young stud is just so talented, I don't know how they keep him off the field.

I imagine it'll be a competition through "fall camp" (which is roughly about the 1st two weeks of practice, IIRC) but when it ends, CKD will have to make a decision when it comes to install time and whichever one it is will need all the snaps they can get. It may be something we don't even know in terms of an announcement, but one of them needs the majority of snaps.

Knowing what we know now, I'll be surprised if KR doesn't emerge as the starter, but, whoever starts, I imagine both of them will play the first game or two.
 
If the QB competition between KR and AM is more or less even at this point, who has the higher ceiling? If KR in one redshirt year has already pulled even with AM and all his experience in this system, how can that not be KR? In this new era of college football, it seems to me that you always need to err on the side of exceptional talent when you have the opportunity.
 
If the QB competition between KR and AM is more or less even at this point, who has the higher ceiling? If KR in one redshirt year has already pulled even with AM and all his experience in this system, how can that not be KR? In this new era of college football, it seems to me that you always need to err on the side of exceptional talent when you have the opportunity.
I agree 100%.

When it was said they were virtually even (except for experience in the system), I said the same thing, but this was before KR showed out on A-day.

He's also the one who can make more plays "off-platform," and with a brand new OL, that skill will come into play.
 
Hope he's more durable than Tua...
Tua's consistent problem, including his career in the NFL was that, no matter what the defense did, Tua was convinced that if he waited long enough, someone would get open. Sometimes the defense wins. Tua never learned that, until he got clobbered by the defense (which will inevitably happen if you wait too long to throw it away).
If the defense has the right defense called, then throw the ball away and live to play another down. Punting is not failure, unless you are down big late in the game.
 
In the video, you can see our OL doing some good things. If the only thing they clean up is the total busted plays where 1 or 2 don't block anybody, we'll be a lot better!!!

Amen... The bar is pretty low for the OL to be better. Watching the scrimmage it looked like they were getting to their man and holding blocks and even getting to the second level. Definitely better than the disorganized disaster of last year, where even if the picked up the right guy they got blown up way to often.
 
Amen... The bar is pretty low for the OL to be better. Watching the scrimmage it looked like they were getting to their man and holding blocks and even getting to the second level. Definitely better than the disorganized disaster of last year, where even if the picked up the right guy they got blown up way to often.

Thanks for mentioning this. I wasn't able to go to A Day and I had a friend go and I told him to "take notes". But he said he totally forgot to pay attention to the OL and was watching other things, so he couldn't comment.
 
Thanks for mentioning this. I wasn't able to go to A Day and I had a friend go and I told him to "take notes". But he said he totally forgot to pay attention to the OL and was watching other things, so he couldn't comment.

I saw some of the longer highlight reels and they looked improved, but take that with a grain of salt, because I freely admit I'm not good at OL eval.
 
And Sanders and Fields did not play and one or both could be our starting guards next year (if Carrol moves back to RT).

Hopefully our top 7-8 guys are fully healthy heading into the fall, have a good conditioning run in the summer, and we can select the top 5 quickly and just rep the heck out of them as a unit with an extra tackle and and extra interior player ready to go. I can't see how the revolving chairs helped anything last year.
 
Advertisement

Trending content

Advertisement

Latest threads