Search results

  1. G

    Why has Bama been terrible on both sides of the line for 4 or 5 years?

    Oh, I agree. Not advocating for the full-bore Leach offense. Just noting its similarities to our scheme. We aren’t ever going to be a team that routinely pounds the ball 40 times a game for 250 yards under DeBoer, but we need to get to a level where the run game is at least respectable. I...
  2. G

    Coaching carousel 2025-26

    I sincerely hope there’s nothing to this and that CKD sticks around. That said, here are the only reasons I can think of that he might make this move: 1) It’s closer to where he grew up, and he spent time as OC about 8 miles down the road in Ypslanti. 2) Courtney Morgan is a UM alum. 3) It’s...
  3. G

    Why has Bama been terrible on both sides of the line for 4 or 5 years?

    IMO, the offensive and defensive lines have more bad recruiting revaluations than other position groups - and I mean across college football. I think it can be inherently difficult to evaluate because human beings that are 6’5, 300+ pounds and reasonably athletic are rare in general, and...
  4. G

    Bama Game Thread: Official PostGame Thread - Bama vs. UGA...

    Look, yesterday was no fun. I don’t know whether this team makes the playoff. I’m not sure they can get healthy enough to make a run if they do. This was still a very good season for a second-year coach navigating the SEC in the NIL era. We won 10 games, beat all of our rivals, were the first...
  5. G

    Coaching carousel 2025-26

    Yeah, the PSU community seems to think those are the only two viable options at this point. There’s a handful of them that still seem to think DeBoer is a legit option and that the AD is just waiting until the end of the season, or at least until after this weekend. There’s been some pushback...
  6. G

    Coaching carousel 2025-26

    I was perusing their message boards out of sheer curiosity. Their fans were all-in on making a run at DeBoer if we lost the Iron Bowl, but they seemed to have moved on. A lot of them wanted Chesney from JMU but it looks like UCLA has hired him. There’s a prominent poster on Black Shoe Diaries...
  7. G

    Would you prefer Lane Kiffin to coach Bama over KD?

    Moot point because we’ve been told repeatedly by people with connections that it’s not happening under current UA leadership. Too much bad behavior from Kiffin during his time in Tuscaloosa. There was a reason he didn’t even get a call when CNS retired. Coaching aside, I would argue that he’s...
  8. G

    Pick the score: Iron Bowl Edition

    Totally agreed on paper. The problem is that these metrics were very similar in ‘21 and ‘23, and it took 4 OTs and a highly improbable hero play, respectively, to win those games. In fact, you could make a solid argument that our ‘21 and ‘23 teams were better than this season’s team. This game...
  9. G

    Coaching carousel 2025-26

    Ok, fair enough. I think if you look at collective career performance, CKD again was the correct choice. I preferred CKD to Norvell at the time, but I wouldn’t have been disappointed with Norvell. His FSU teams had gone 3-6, 5-7, 10-3 and 13-1 after inheriting the mess Willie Taggart left, and...
  10. G

    CFN: Alabama vs Auburn Prediction: Can the Tide Finish the Job?

    In terms of personnel, this Auburn team reminds me of South Carolina as far as teams we’ve faced this season. Athletic QB, questionable offensive line, underutilized skill players, a nasty defensive line and a secondary that can be had if you can hit the throws. Auburn has been less...
  11. G

    Coaching carousel 2025-26

    The point with Norvell is that no one would have thought it was an idiotic hire in January 2024. He was 23-4 at FSU the two prior seasons and had just finished an undefeated regular season with a conference title. We have the benefit of hindsight now, of course. At the time, he would have been...
  12. G

    Coaching carousel 2025-26

    Yeah, the mainstream media narrative that DeBoer was handed the keys to a Ferrari and turned it into an F150 misses the mark. Saban’s 2021 & 2022 teams were 8-4 or 9-3 teams without Bryce Young. Heck, the 2022 team still lost 2 regular season games. 2023 was perhaps his strongest front-to-back...
  13. G

    The way too early discussion on whether Ty Simpson should return next season or enter the draft

    Is that because you think Mack has seen the writing on the wall with Russell? Or is that because you think Ty comes back for 2026? Or something else entirely? Just curious. I wouldn’t blame him - but with Russell getting more reps on Saturday, do we know that Russell has more or less supplanted...
  14. G

    The way too early discussion on whether Ty Simpson should return next season or enter the draft

    I agree, but I also think they’ll be able to get consistent pressure with 4-5 guys. The tape on us now dictates that a defense should line the ends up wide against the tackles, and keep an LB and safety in a soft zone in the intermediate middle of the field. This makes Ty uncomfortable in the...
  15. G

    The way too early discussion on whether Ty Simpson should return next season or enter the draft

    Mack has looked great in limited action this season (and I believe he’s the starter in 2026), but the quality of the opponents must be considered. Also take into account that Milroe was never benched last season - and I’m also convinced that he played the back half of 2024 with some sort of...
  16. G

    Auburn hate week:

    Here’s my issue with Auburn: growing up, I went to church with a lot of Auburn fans / graduates, and I work with a number of AU grads as well. There’s this “holier than thou” attitude that seems to permeate that fan base, or at least the more highly educated end of the spectrum. They are similar...
  17. G

    Coaching carousel 2025-26

    I agree in terms of cumulative tradition. That said, LSU and Florida both have multiple national titles since the mid 1990s - in LSU’s case, they had one six years ago - so I think in terms of the “modern era”, an argument could be made. Outside of a handful of seasons under Cutcliffe, Freeze...
  18. G

    Coaching carousel 2025-26

    These guys all tend to have massive egos, whether they project it or not. If Kiffin leaves Ole Miss, it will happen because he thinks he’s good enough to restore a blue-blood to championship levels. That’s it. I doubt money is even all that important, because lord knows none of these guys are...
  19. G

    The way too early discussion on whether Ty Simpson should return next season or enter the draft

    If Ty gets a 1st round grade, I think he’d be crazy not to leave. He’s got his degree and has played four seasons of college ball. Russell gets a lot of hype - and I’m not saying the hype isn’t warranted - but don’t forget about Austin Mack. The staff is still really high on him from what I’ve...
  20. G

    Coaching carousel 2025-26

    Shifting gears a bit, but I do think James Franklin is a good hire for VT. The guy recruits like a madman, so at a minimum they’ll be one of the most talented teams in the ACC in the next 2-3 seasons. He usually hires competent coordinators as well. I could be wrong, but I think this hire...
Advertisement

Trending content

Advertisement

Latest threads