Stop Bashing Posts and Posters

4Q Basket Case

FB|BB Moderator
Staff member
Nov 8, 2004
11,323
18,282
537
Tuscaloosa
Guys, you've got to stop the denigration of others' posts.

Disagree all you want. But don't call another post or poster or their position, "stupid" or "ludicrous" or anything of the sort.

Say you don't understand the logic and politely ask the poster to explain. Say you see the issue differently and present your own logic.

But stop with the bashing of posts and / or posters. It took a while and some unpleasant actions to get that toned down on the NSPR board, but we finally made good progress there. We still have plenty of debate, but the nastiness and rancor are way down, and the quality of the debate is much higher.

We as a Mod team learned from that effort. The primary lesson being that some people are just hard-wired to view an opposing opinion as a personal insult coming from an obviously inferior human being who has equally obvious mental impairments.

We can't fix people who think that way. We can fix what they are able to post on TideFans.

On the Football board, recent warnings and reminders haven't worked as well as we would have liked. With the season approaching, consider this a last chance reminder.

Debate all you want. That's what TideFans is for. Just don't bash. If you can't refrain from that, there will be no further begging....we'll handle it for you.
 
Last edited:
Quick question. Is replying "MOO" to a brand new poster consider bashing??
Within reasonable limits, no.

If MOO becomes the go-to way of expressing disagreement, we’ll revisit.

And before somebody asks, “reasonable” is in the mind of the Moderator.

BamaNation, Crimsonaudio and Tide-Hsv hold the rest of the mod team to a standard of reasonableness, and we all serve at BamaNation’s pleasure. If they feel that a mod is being unreasonable, they can fix that easily.

Put another way, if you have to ask whether you’re being reasonable, you’re probably not.
 
Aw man, and right when I had the perfect comeback that involved asserting one's simian ancestry. Oh well, there's always X.....
 
It's a small mind that bashes other people in trying to make themselves look good...
It’s not necessary to make themselves look good, it can be about saying something the wrong way.

I said something someone said was stupid, because it was.

But that probably crossed the line.

I could have said it was ill-advised and that would theoretically be acceptable.

Some referred to bashing people as “childish”…is that comment bashing people? I don’t think so but I guess it could be.

Is your “small mind” comment bashing?

Seems to me some would say yes and some would say no.

But perhaps it’s because you said it generically and not directly to one poster?

To me it’s more like the difference between what I would say in court as opposed to what I would say about the same topic sitting at a bar.

I will commit to being more mindful and more professional here.
 

New Posts

Advertisement

Trending content

Advertisement

Latest threads