What are you reading right now (II)?

Just finished, “When Winter Came,” by Mary Beth Sartor Obermeyer. It’s about the author’s grandfather. He was a country doctor in rural Iowa during the flu pandemic of 1918-19.

It gets good reviews, and I expected to be impressed. I was underwhelmed.

The doctor’s personal story is impressive, going back to a frail childhood in Luxembourg, to family support through medical school in Chicago to a long and respected career as a rural GP in Iowa. Well done, Dr. Sartor.

But the book was beyond a tribute to the author’s grandfather. It was a paean, getting on toward sanctification.

Out of a 300-page book, only about 65 pages are devoted to what the title would lead you to expect. There are way too many imagined conversations, way too much energy devoted to establishing a scantily-documented connection with the Mayo Clinic, and way too much dewey-eyed devotion to a man who I’m sure was an inspirational grandfather.

So I liked about 65 out of 300 pages — a bit over 20%. The rest was genealogical research and a sentimental tribute to a grandfather.

And yes, I’m the minority of one that thought Field of Dreams was stupid.
 
Last edited:
Advertisement

Trending content

Advertisement

Latest threads