2006 is probably the worst year. That mainly has to do with the 2002 class, I think (recruited by Fran, actually signed by Price), and not so much with ability, but with lack of contribution to the program for the long haul. The HS guys signed that year, in terms of eligibility, either graduated last year or were fifth year seniors this year.
First, only about twenty signed letters of intent. A few of 'em were JUCOs (Zach Fletcher, David Scott, Derrick Pope), so they were gone after a couple of years. Two, I think, played four years without a redshirt, DeMeco Ryans and Moose McLain, who I think was hurt most of the time.
That left us with about 15 possible players who could have been five year guys this year. Only six of those ended up on the roster, four starters (Darby, Robinson, Simpson and Clark) and two backups (Tatum and Harris).
Avalos quit school, Chris Browder ended up at Auburn, Chauncy Malone, Earnest Nance, Titus Ryan, & Henry Smith never made it to campus for one reason or another. Two guys transferred, Nic Luke, and Grant Dickey, who followed Fran to
A & M.
'03's numbers were low, too; I think we only signed 17, and about five of them aren't on the team now, although they would be either 4 year seniors like McClain and Castille, or redshirt juniors like Capps and Caddell if they were still around. Another casualty from that class, sadly, is Prothro.
Just for comparison purposes, Auburn's entire starting offensive line yesterday was signed in '02 or '03. Cope, a senior, walked on. Other names from AU's lineup from those classes are Brandon Cox, Carl Stewart, Courtney Taylor, Cole Bennett (injured early this year), Lee Guess, Quentin Groves, Marquies Gunn, Josh Thompson, Karibi Dede, Will Herring, David Irons, Tre Smith and both the punter Bliss and the kicker Vaughn.