Sidebar

Colbysullivan (was right about Jalen Milroe)

Status
Not open for further replies.
E

Easttexastide

BamaNation Citizen
Sep 10, 2023
47
88
37
Is the MVP

He was always right. He might even be a coach idk but he was always right.
What Milroe did wrong you have to learn in junior high it's no changing that athletes may start off at qb but by high-school they are playing other positions. All off-season we were told he has improved I found it hard to believe because the things he does wrong you can't coach or change you either have it or you don't.

We have always won despite him not because of him. Minus the two Georgia games who like our old D the two gap system is bad against a mobile qb. We wasted a great team last year because of his play in the rose bowl.

The aggie game sums up his career here. Hurry up the offense while we are running the clock out gets Seth to snap it and the one hops a throw to wide open wide receiver. The guy was wide open because we should have been running clock out not passing it. I've seen junior high players have a bad game and then fall apart this guy at the first sign of adversity lays it down because he doesn't have the qb skill level to change things.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rja4bama, BamaHoopsBoi, SkullDuckery and 8 others
6

64 Grad

BamaNation Citizen
Oct 29, 2023
95
116
52
Milroe is not a good quarterback. Oklahoma's defense dominated the game. This was mainly because they were ready for this offense supposedly built around Milroe's skill set. It was a pathetic offensive performance and the defense was not much better. Hat's off the Oklahoma's coaching staff. After the LSU game I was complimenting our coaching staff. I am, like this team, up and down like a yo yo, but I am not paid the big bucks like the coaching staff and players. Paying the players has changed team chemistry. I did see where some people were attending a burial service for LANK. It will be interesting to see where Alabama ends up over time in the new paradigm of college football.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tusks_n_raider, Rush, GeorgiaTider and 2 others
The Ols

The Ols

Hall of Fame
Jul 8, 2012
5,540
6,519
187
Cumming,Ga.
64 Grad said:
Milroe is not a good quarterback. Oklahoma's defense dominated the game. This was mainly because they were ready for this offense supposedly built around Milroe's skill set. It was a pathetic offensive performance and the defense was not much better. Hat's off the Oklahoma's coaching staff. After the LSU game I was complimenting our coaching staff. I am, like this team, up and down like a yo yo, but I am not paid the big bucks like the coaching staff and players. Paying the players has changed team chemistry. I did see where some people were attending a burial service for LANK. It will be interesting to see where Alabama ends up over time in the new paradigm of college football.
Click to expand...
A burial service 🤣…
Pick up the pace…make it a cremation.
 
Cruloc

Cruloc

Hall of Fame
Sep 1, 2019
6,898
12,213
187
Easttexastide said:
Is the MVP

He was always right. He might even be a coach idk but he was always right.
What Milroe did wrong you have to learn in junior high it's no changing that athletes may start off at qb but by high-school they are playing other positions. All off-season we were told he has improved I found it hard to believe because the things he does wrong you can't coach or change you either have it or you don't.

We have always won despite him not because of him. Minus the two Georgia games who like our old D the two gap system is bad against a mobile qb. We wasted a great team last year because of his play in the rose bowl.

The aggie game sums up his career here. Hurry up the offense while we are running the clock out gets Seth to snap it and the one hops a throw to wide open wide receiver. The guy was wide open because we should have been running clock out not passing it. I've seen junior high players have a bad game and then fall apart this guy at the first sign of adversity lays it down because he doesn't have the qb skill level to change things.
Click to expand...
colby....did you make another login?
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: UAllday, crimsonaudio, AlexanderFan and 1 other person
R

REBELZED

All-American
Dec 6, 2006
4,079
1,295
187
64 Grad said:
This was mainly because they were ready for this offense supposedly built around Milroe's skill set.
Click to expand...
Not to beat the dead horse but they are trying to build a jet (well-oiled offense) using dog poo (poor QB skillset/play). The most confusing thing about it is this is the second different coaching staff to have the same problem with the same player.

It is especially confusing when there are multiple other highly-recruited QB's sitting on our bench. We'll never know the whole story, but I will go to my grave not believing how one exceedingly unqualified player choked the throat of a normally-championship-level program for multiple years...
 
  • Like
  • Thank You
Reactions: Toddrn, SkullDuckery, Ttown13 and 5 others
JTBama

JTBama

All-American
Jul 2, 2005
2,683
15
57
47
Some where out there
While Milroe may not be the answer ...it ultimately falls on the head coach. Milroe is playing qb because the coach has refused to pull him. I can give my opinion on his capabilities as a qb, but I can't fault him for playing qb . That's a decision Deboer must face , the question is does CKD make a change for the future or does he finish out a season that's primarily down to a bowl game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Toddrn, Rkharley98 and B1GTide
JTBama

JTBama

All-American
Jul 2, 2005
2,683
15
57
47
Some where out there
Easttexastide said:
Is the MVP

He was always right. He might even be a coach idk but he was always right.
What Milroe did wrong you have to learn in junior high it's no changing that athletes may start off at qb but by high-school they are playing other positions. All off-season we were told he has improved I found it hard to believe because the things he does wrong you can't coach or change you either have it or you don't.

We have always won despite him not because of him. Minus the two Georgia games who like our old D the two gap system is bad against a mobile qb. We wasted a great team last year because of his play in the rose bowl.

The aggie game sums up his career here. Hurry up the offense while we are running the clock out gets Seth to snap it and the one hops a throw to wide open wide receiver. The guy was wide open because we should have been running clock out not passing it. I've seen junior high players have a bad game and then fall apart this guy at the first sign of adversity lays it down because he doesn't have the qb skill level to change things.
Click to expand...

I'll also add that I've had my fair share of criticisms of him but when you say "we've won despite not because of him"..I remember him throwing an Ace of a bomb to Bond in the iron bowl to win that one. He's won some and he's lost some
 
DzynKingRTR

DzynKingRTR

TideFans Legend
Dec 17, 2003
46,661
37,152
287
Vinings, ga., usa
JTBama said:
I'll also add that I've had my fair share of criticisms of him but when you say "we've won despite not because of him"..I remember him throwing an Ace of a bomb to Bond in the iron bowl to win that one. He's won some and he's lost some
Click to expand...
The play before that though when he was well passed the line of scrimmage and still threw the ball. He easily had the first down or maybe even scores, but he threw it.
 
  • Like
  • Thank You
Reactions: RammerJammer14, colbysullivan, The Ols and 1 other person
JTBama

JTBama

All-American
Jul 2, 2005
2,683
15
57
47
Some where out there
What does the play before have to do with the final play? The play going past the line didn't lose it, the final play won it. If we are blaming him for the previous play, why are we not crediting him for the final.play? You're giving credit to Auburn. The Bama fans cheering for that win at the stadium and on TV were not cheering Auburns bad defensive play, they were cheering Milroe and bonds throw and catch. I think herbstreit called it one of the best drawn up and executed plays he's seen on a hailmary.
 
JTBama

JTBama

All-American
Jul 2, 2005
2,683
15
57
47
Some where out there
It's funny how some can criticize him for bad play but fail to remember cheering for him when scored. If you want to blame someone for him playing qb...pick up the phone and call CKD. He's doing the only thing he can...which is playing qb. I won't criticize his personality but I'll give him credit and criticize his performance when needed.
 
The Ols

The Ols

Hall of Fame
Jul 8, 2012
5,540
6,519
187
Cumming,Ga.
JTBama said:
What does the play before have to do with the final play? The play going past the line didn't lose it, the final play won it. If we are blaming him for the previous play, why are we not crediting him for the final.play? You're giving credit to Auburn. The Bama fans cheering for that win at the stadium and on TV were not cheering Auburns bad defensive play, they were cheering Milroe and bonds throw and catch. I think herbstreit called it one of the best drawn up and executed plays he's seen on a hailmary.
Click to expand...
Boogs gifted us that game…even Uncle Hugh admits it…move along.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SkullDuckery and AlexanderFan
Status
Not open for further replies.

New Posts

|

Latest threads

Top Bottom