As you say, Identity politics is not sustainable in the digital social media and now emerging AI age because identities can be micro-segmented. Message/Agenda politics is taking over.Mainstream Democrats have let their party and positions be defined by the far left and Republicans. Identity politics has destroyed the image of the party in the minds of many.
Most Democrats are certainly not anti-white, anti-male, or anti-Christian. But perception drives politics, and when the loudest voices sound like they are scolding or judging instead of persuading, voters tune out.
That is a real problem with those who might otherwise agree with us on jobs, healthcare, and the cost of living but feel like they are being lectured by intolerant extremists.
This is not about attacking progressives. It is about recognizing that tone and messaging shape how the entire party is seen.
If we want to rebuild trust and win elections, we need to sound like we actually want people on our side. There has been more than enough ammunition provided by Trump for Democrats to run on. Trotting out the same old message of division isn’t going to get the job done.
