2021 World Series Rematch: Houston Astros (77-43) at Atlanta Braves (73-47)

selmaborntidefan

TideFans Legend
Mar 31, 2000
38,134
33,169
287
55
Those idiots retired Paul O’Neill’s number today.

And now you know why I never take their whines for Thurman Munson and Don Mattingly seriously. If you think Paul O’Neill is worthy of a retired number, your opinion is rendered unworthy of respect.
 
  • Thank You
  • Like
Reactions: UAH and TexasBama

selmaborntidefan

TideFans Legend
Mar 31, 2000
38,134
33,169
287
55
Posada and Bernie Williams were All-Time legends

Didn't realize they'd made a joke of it.


1Billy MartinAugust 10th, 1986
2Derek JeterMay 14, 2017
3Babe RuthJune 13th, 1948
4Lou GehrigJuly 4th, 1939**
5Joe DiMaggioApril 18th, 1952
6Joe TorreAugust 23, 2014
7Mickey MantleJune 8th, 1969
8Yogi BerraJuly 22nd, 1972
8Bill DickeyJuly 22nd, 1972
9Roger MarisJuly 22nd, 1984*
10Phil RizzutoAugust 4th, 1985
15Thurman MunsonSeptember 20th, 1980
16Whitey FordAugust 3rd, 1974
20Jorge PosadaAugust 22nd, 2015
21Paul O'NeillAugust 21st, 2022
23Don MattinglyAugust 31st, 1997
32Elston HowardJuly 22nd, 1984*
37Casey StengelAugust 8th, 1970
42Mariano RiveraSeptember 22, 2013
44Reggie JacksonAugust 14th, 1993
46Andy PettitteAugust 23rd, 2015
49Ron GuidryAugust 23rd, 2003
51Bernie WilliamsMay 24th, 2015


Numbers 1-8 are all easily defensible; they're all Hall of Famers, and some (Ruth, Gehrig, Mantle) are in the top five players of their position of all-time. Okay, Martin is NOT in the Hall, but he should be. Whitey, Reggie, Stengel, Rivera - all defensible.

Phil Rizzuto's was EXPLICITLY DONE to get him into the HOF. He has no business there. And eventually he got in in part because of that nonsense.

Munson's is defensible, too, especially with the circumstances of his death, the fact he was captain, and he WAS good catcher.

Posada? So awesome he didn't become the starting catcher until age 28. Seven of the most similar players to him are NOT in the Hall and one (Roy Campanella) had a shortened career on both ends (segregation on the front, the accident on the back).

Mattingly - a great player for four years who never won a World Series....playing for....the Yankees....

Elston Howard? Guilty white northerners want to honor the black dude (who was an average player)

Pettite? A joke.

Bernie Williams? An even bigger joke.

Maris? Get out of town.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TexasBama

bvandegraff

Hall of Fame
Mar 13, 2014
5,200
5,862
187
Albuquerque, NM
Lee did this last night, allowed 3 of the first 4 he face to reach base. Now he’s screwed over again.

Now we are going to Stephens. Ugh!

Why is it always Lee and Stephens back to back out of the bullpen?
Snitker's bullpen management is dubious at best. Good thing the ATL media will ask Snit the tough questions and hold him to account in the post-game...
 

New Posts

Amazon Deals for TideFans!

YouTheFan Alabama BBQ Set

Purchases may result in a commission being paid to TideFans.

Latest threads