A few thoughts on our team, our program, and everything else...

BigEasyTider

FB | REC Moderator
Nov 27, 2007
10,029
0
0
After yet another disappointing loss tonight, I figured I would post a few personal thoughts on our team, our program, and just about everything else. Here goes:

Just to start this long, rambling post off, I must admit that it is just so frustrating to follow this team. We play hard, no doubt about that, but every game I follow, I have this lingering thought rolling around in the back of my head, "Just how are we going to throw this one away?" And, unfortunately, more often that not, those fears are realized.

I don't pretend to be an expert in these matters, but I've been following Alabama baseball for about three decades now, and I cannot remember a team that has struggled so greatly to consistent execute even the most elementary of baseball fundamentals. We are 11th in the SEC in walks, and we lead the SEC in strikeouts; we chase pitches in the dirt and then watch fastballs go down Main Street with the bat on the shoulder. Combine that with a poor power hitting team -- near the bottom in slugging percentage -- and we can't score runs. Defensively, we've committed the most errors of any team in the conference, have the worst fielding percentage in the conference and have the most passed balls of any team in the conference. Pitching is just as bad, honestly. We lead the conference by a mile in both walks allowed, balks, and wild pitches. And we are second to last in ERA. How could we really get any worse on the fundamentals?

Again, I've never seen a team struggle so greatly to consistently execute even the most elementary of baseball fundamentals. I cannot recall how many games we've lost this year just because we cannot do the most simple tasks. We lost at LSU, for example, on a wild pitch, and we lost tonight to Southern Miss after giving up four unearned runs when we could not make a simple throw from shortstop to first base. If we could just play fundamental baseball with any consistency, we would be a lock to at least make Hoover and perhaps even the NCAA Tournament.

The crazy thing, though, is as bad as we've been, we're still tied for second in the SEC West. But I really don't think we should read too much into that. It really is hard to fathom just how terrible the SEC West is at the moment, aside from Ole Miss. UNO beat LSU tonight in New Orleans -- thus sweeping the season series with the Bayou Bengals, and they swept us earlier in the year -- and I am absolutely convinced they would be running away with second right now if they were in the SEC West. Though we are currently in a three-way tie for second, I think that has more to do with the fact that the rest of the West is so weak more so than a sign that we are of any real quality.

So where do we go from here?

Being brutally honest, the odds are against us even making the SEC Tournament. And truthfully, the likely scenario is that -- even if we do get to Hoover -- that we don't last very long before we get eliminated. We would probably last three games at most, and of course it's a foregone conclusion that we will not be making the NCAA Tournament this year.

At this point, in terms of any real on-field success, I think we're probably looking at 2009. For all of the struggles of this season, I suppose the good news is that we really don't have any seniors on this team. Looking at the 2009 campaign, we are only going to lose three seniors -- Josh Copeland, Will Stroup, and Matt Bentley. None of those three are bad players, mind you, but I really cannot see where they are all of that great, and I'm not thinking that we'll have any major problems replacing them. For all of our struggles this year, at least we return just about everyone for 2009.

The interesting thing, I think, is that this roster is so heavy with juniors. So many players who are key parts for us are juniors, and you just can't overlook that. Avila, Sharp, Kubal, Matthes, Odle, Rhoden, Texada, Hyatt, Kebodeaux, etc., are all juniors. In fact, over 50% of the total roster consists of juniors. That's very interesting to me in regard to 2009, because that means all of those guys will be seniors. It really does make you wonder, because you have to figure if we cannot get something going in 2009 with so many seniors, it's going to be really rough in 2010 once we have to suddenly replace all of those guys.

It's hard to say exactly where we are now. I do criticize Coach Wells a fair amount during the games for some decisions, but I'm not going to sit here and bash the man. He has, on the whole, done very well at Alabama, and we should all be extremely proud of what he has accomplished. He took over in 1995 -- just after arguably the worst season in modern Alabama baseball history -- and has done really well since. We made the NCAA Tournament nine out of his first eleven years, won the SEC, made the CWS twice, and even made the national title game in 1997. And that's not counting six SEC Tournament championships, or the fact that he is the all-time winningest manager in Alabama baseball history. I'm not going to sit here and bash the man, I'm proud of what he has done here at Alabama and you should be too.

However, I would be lying if I said that I was not afraid the magic is gone.

It's just seems different now. Last year we didn't have a very good year, barely squeaking into the SEC Tournament and not making the NCAA Tournament. And now this year we probably won't even make Hoover in what is one of the worst years we've had at Alabama under Wells -- and in terms of overall record, it might very well be the worst year we've had under him. Things just don't seem to be like they used to be at the Joe.

And I would also be equally a liar if I were to say that I did not think a lot of the blame lays at the feet of Wells. I understand we don't have the most talented roster in the conference, but everyone at this level should be able to play good fundamental baseball, so the lack of good fundamentals for us reflects heavily on Wells. And honestly, we have been hurt a good bit this year by Wells' constantly baffling in-game managerial decisions.

I hope it all returns, I really do. But I'm just not sure that it will. If you look at how bad 2007 and 2008 have been -- and how we're probably going to struggle in 2010 replacing so many players -- 2009 might be the critical year for Wells at Alabama. Unless we really improve and return to our old ways, that may mark the end of his tenure at Alabama, even if only effectively and not officially.

At this point, I just don't know, but things just don't seem right.

But that's enough ramblings for one night.
 
Last edited:
Nice post. You are right the magic is gone. Hey this guy took us to 3 CWS and like to have won one and I am pleased with that and what ever happens shouldn't be taken away from what he has done. With that said it's time to be truthful and tell it like it is he is not doing his job now for whatever reason. We play hard and we don't quit but it takes more that to win games and series. Playing hard dosen't mean you hate to lose We don't compete in every at bat on every pitch or every throw like it could be our last. we let the game come to us or by pass before we can take charge of the situation. Teams that do well, teams that you hate to play sound mentally tough teams REFUSE TO LOSE. They would rather you slap their mother than LOSE one at bat one play in the field or on a pitch. That is what is missing from this team and this program because that is the way we used to play. Nobody wanted to come to the Joe and play us or play us period because they knew they were going to have to bring their lunch box to beat us. I wish Jim could get us back there but he just can't do it. Plenty of blame to go around are AD is not helping this program out any either. Teams usually play to personallity of thier coach or the biggest compliment would be coach Wells teams are tough to play but that not the case. We are not doing little things or we are not asking our players to do the little thing in practice that it takes to win games. Before Iget baned or deleted whatever the truth of the matter is this team is soft just like thier coach they do not REFUSE TO LOSE. When we start to do that we will get better and it needs to start now in the Ad's office down to the field of play or it's not going to better.
 
I said before the season that starting pitching was the big question. When the starters go deep were in ballgames. I'll be the first to agree that 67 errors and 18 balks are unbelievealbe numbers along with the passballs etc. But when you start 2 true freshman at the middle infield positions along with a guy new to catching your not just asking for problems, your screaming out loud for problems. things have not been helped with Jake Smith's batting woes although scoring runs for this team is not a huge problem. If you want one mans solution, move May back to 2nd base and Texada to short (although Texada has had his fielding problems) but at least he has played it at a SEC level before,and put Mike Sharp behind the plate permently andplay Avilia at third While Jake is struggling and please please play just a little small ball!!!!! As far as all the juniors on the team, CJW is going to have to ask a lot of them not to return due to the roster limitations starting next year. no way you can lose more than half your team with very few schlorships to offer, but you can look at other SEC rosters and see other teams will have that problem too. (why do you think Polk is quitting). It is very frustrating but I will keep pullin' for tis team ROLL TIDE forever.
 
It's nearly impossible to replace your C, SS, 2B & CF in one year and expect to be a good defensive team, UNLESS you have outstanding pitching.

That's why the old saying "You have to be strong up the middle" is still true after 100+ years.

Giving up unearned runs on defense puts a lot of pressure on the offense, which in turn leads to bad at-bats.
 
It's nearly impossible to replace your C, SS, 2B & CF in one year and expect to be a good defensive team, UNLESS you have outstanding pitching.

That's why the old saying "You have to be strong up the middle" is still true after 100+ years.

Giving up unearned runs on defense puts a lot of pressure on the offense, which in turn leads to bad at-bats.


agreed
 
Big Easy, that's a great post, but I read it with a slightly different viewpoint. it seems to me that this looks less like a baseball problem and more like an Athletic Department problem. Up until this year, you could have made many of the exact same comments about our football program. Now we're getting that one straightened out. But you can also say t he exact same thing about the basketball program. If you go on the basketball board you will read numerous posts quoting your words almost verbatim, with individual sport references and coaching names being the only exceptions.
Regardless of which sport you speak of, it seems to me the real and most imperative issue is a lack of discipline and dedication within our sports programs. Without fail this results in games lost because of lack of S&C on the part of the players and lack of fundamental coaching on the part of the coaches.
IMO this is not a minor issue in each individual sports program. It's a cancer and it's spreading throughout the entire athletic program at The University.
 
It's nearly impossible to replace your C, SS, 2B & CF in one year and expect to be a good defensive team, UNLESS you have outstanding pitching.

I agree completely with that, but...

I'm not complaining that we are not a good defensive team. I'm complaining that we are, by far, the worst defensive team in the entire conference in all three major defensive metrics.

I understand a drop-off was expected when the entire middle defense had to be replaced, but nothing like this. I know it creates a tough situation, and I'm not complaining that we are not great defensively, but there is no way you can rationally tell me that by replacing the middle defense we should be dead last by a mile in all major defensive metrics. I know we shouldn't be a good defensive team, but likewise there is no way we should be this bad.

Big Easy, that's a great post, but I read it with a slightly different viewpoint. it seems to me that this looks less like a baseball problem and more like an Athletic Department problem. Up until this year, you could have made many of the exact same comments about our football program. Now we're getting that one straightened out. But you can also say t he exact same thing about the basketball program. If you go on the basketball board you will read numerous posts quoting your words almost verbatim, with individual sport references and coaching names being the only exceptions.
Regardless of which sport you speak of, it seems to me the real and most imperative issue is a lack of discipline and dedication within our sports programs. Without fail this results in games lost because of lack of S&C on the part of the players and lack of fundamental coaching on the part of the coaches.
IMO this is not a minor issue in each individual sports program. It's a cancer and it's spreading throughout the entire athletic program at The University.

I agree with you to an extent. It was a problem in football, basketball, and baseball.

The football thing was troubling but it was understandable. We struggled in it, but realistically we were on probation -- or under the effects of -- and we were trying to make it work with a lame duck head coach who we really never wanted to hire in the first place. Again, not saying it wasn't a problem, but it was understandable, and we have fixed that with Saban now at the helm.

Basketball and baseball are different stories, though. Both the baseball and the basketball programs have atrophied from previous highs under the same coaches. To be quite frank, I'm not so sure that it's an athletic department problem as much as it is a problem that the two coaches -- Gottfried and Wells -- have been around so long that some complacency has set in. Combined, those two guys have been head coaches at Alabama for almost twenty-five years now, and it's somewhat hard to argue that some change wouldn't do both programs good at this point.

The other thing that keeps me from saying it is an athletic department problem is the overall success of other sports teams at Alabama. In many other sports, we are having a lot of success. Gymnastics is doing great as usual, and both softball and men's golf could end up with national championships this year. Beyond that, women's golf is a top ten program, and both men's tennis and women's tennis are in the top twenty. We are actually having a lot of success in other sports, and football seems to be back on the right track; really it seems like baseball and basketball are the only two major stragglers right now. That kind of keeps me from thinking it is an overall AD problem.
 

New Posts

Advertisement

Trending content

Advertisement

Latest threads