Some people are definitely a little out there with their Ty takes if that's what you mean. Don't disagree.
Alabama QBs in 2024, II
- Thread starter 4Q Basket Case
- Start date
-
Hi Guest, we are working on updating the site servers and software. We're also 'forcing' everyone to read and agree to our site privacy policy and terms of service. There are no significant changes to either of these but the terms page does clarify a few things that are mostly in the legalese. You can just click the checkbox for both and continue using the site as usual! We'll update you more on the site upgrades VERY soon! THANK YOU AS ALWAYS for supporting the site and being an active participant!
Ok that’s what I thought you meant, just wanted to make sure. Thanks.
Given the circumstances and the end result, Ty showed enough to earn the start against Ole Miss IMO. The OL just refused to play for him or Buckner that day.
Everybody on here is an armchair QB. Including me. I love Milroe as a person but don't think he will ever get to the point that he gets the ball out quickly enough and with enough accuracy to be very successful (win it all). I have no idea what Simpson can do. He literally got to play in one real game last year when it mattered. He might be a great practice player and stink it up when the lights come on.
The good news is that we have a new coach following the best college coach of all time. That new coach's strength is the offense. Oh, and he wins (104-12). I think in the end we can trust that he will put the guy out there who he thinks will give the team the best chance to win.
The good news is that we have a new coach following the best college coach of all time. That new coach's strength is the offense. Oh, and he wins (104-12). I think in the end we can trust that he will put the guy out there who he thinks will give the team the best chance to win.
You have your opinion, I have mine.
Disagreeing with you doesn't mean I'm "absolutely out of my mind" and that I'm "blind" because you think differently.
Disagreeing with you doesn't make me an idiot.
That explains the USF performance; we went to the wrong city!
Too bad there's not a way to do that on Tidefans...
Never said you were an idiot for disagreeing with me. I’m simply saying you’re wrong in this case. The QBs I listed improved over the year significantly. Milroe did not. That’s not an opinion.
The O certainly didn't show up in the right place that day.
And they also had the worst defense of anyone we played
lsu's secondary was just awful last year. They would have made me look good
Here's how I'd look at all those seasons.
As someone else mentioned, AJMac played prior to the offensive modernization in the SEC. You'd expect lower production than comparing against today. Despite that, and despite also playing LSU twice, whose defense was only second to ours that year and was essentially an NFL level defense, AJ progressed that season enough that against the second best defense in college football, the coaches trusted him to throw 34 times.
For Sims, to illustrate growth, I'd look at the last 4 games against ranked teams (taking W Carolina out). 31, 27, 27 and 36 attempts. Against Auburn and Mizzo 74.1 and 85.2% completion rate. Passing yardage was lower than you might think due with that amount of passing, but that offense used the short passing game, very, very extensively to stretch the field horizontally and Blake was pretty darn effective in being decisive, making the right reads/decisions and executing what he should have given the D. Even against LSU, the staff trusted him to pull the trigger 45 times in that game, and then against OSU, the best team we played, he was called on for 36 attempts.
With the 2015 team, we had King Henry to rely on a lot, so the passing numbers aren't as heavy as they might have been but he still had almost 400 passing attempts in the season. Other than ole **** at the start of the year, his heavier pass attempts (in games where he played it out - i.e. not charleston) stayed pretty consistent with perhaps a slight increase in average toward the end and against 3 top 25 teams at the end of the put up pretty good stats even if clemson was a bit of a drop off. MSU is where it really showed though as MSU thought they'd just try to stop DH, and Jake made them pay.
Agreed. It's a new societal thing on all subject matters, mostly political, that has spilled over to message boards.
OK, then say it that way. Saying someone is "out of their mind" and "blind" because they did not see things your way is disrespectful.
Well what’s new? Too many people treat quarterback battles the same way tweens in the 2010s treated twilight arguments. It makes no sense but it has a lot of anger and vitriol.
This is correct.
I think they are also in good faith giving Jalen a chance to keep the job while also being ready to quickly move to Ty if/when the opportunity comes up.
My feeling is that they know from what they see day to day that Ty is better.
But that gameday is a whole other beast. They probably need to see Ty on game day playing better to make the switch.
Imo Jalen will have to have made big strides in the off season to run CKD’s offense at a high level on Gameday against real competition.
It’s possible he’s improved but that wasn’t on display in the spring so I still have big doubts.
Ty can run it. If he can run it on Gameday like he does in practice I just don’t see how he doesn’t move up to QB1.
Latest threads
-
Lawsuit seeks to allow top HS wide receiver to proft from NIL- Started by Bamabuzzard
- Replies: 1
-
CFN: Tennessee vs Alabama Prediction: Who Will Smoke the Victory Cigar?- Started by crimsonaudio
- Replies: 4
-
Link: London Simmons is Having a Great Freshman Season- Started by sanjosecrimson
- Replies: 2
-