Analysis of Saban's Press Conference at 5 ET on 1 JAN 2007

spock*

Suspended
Dec 27, 2006
684
531
112
Woodstock, GA
Posted on Tue, Jan. 02, 2007

Note to Saban: It's your fault rumors persisted

http://cbs4.com/video/?id=27735@wfor.dayport.com

By GREG COTE

gcote@MiamiHerald.com

Nick Saban is gone. Taking his Panama hat to Tuscaloosa. Taking on the ghost of Bear Bryant. Taking $40 million from the University of Alabama. Taking all of his publicly professed commitment to Miami and tossing it into the Tide.

These were the impressions Miami's coach-for-now created and invited Monday with a stunning evasiveness that inflamed all of the speculation, instead of a simple declarative that could have ended it for good. His season-ending news conference at Dolphins headquarters worked like a seminar we'd call, How Not to Kill a Rumor. If this was an exercise in public relations, Nick could only have mishandled it more spectacularly by having O.J. Simpson introduce him and vouch for his truthfulness.

Last week, Saban said flatly, ``I'm not going to be the Alabama coach.''

On Monday, the scurrilous, persistent Tide came at Nick with a mountain of money. With an official offer.

Suddenly, Nick is not saying anything flatly anymore.

Suddenly, he is dodging and tap dancing, taking great umbrage at reporters who would dare do their job by even asking the question.

Dear Nick: Here is what you could have said Monday. You could have said, ``I am flattered by Alabama's interest in me, but it is not mutual. I have instructed my agent to decline all overtures or offers. I am not leaving the Dolphins. Period.''

Instead, you said anything but.

You might also have been forthright by admitting, ``While I have no plans to leave Miami, I owe it to my family to at least consider an offer so lucrative relative to financial stability. Can you blame me?''

Instead, you put yourself squarely in between Monday by implying you were committed to Miami but sidestepping several chances to make that clear.

SABAN AT FAULT

So don't you dare get all offended by the assumptions and doubts you created.

Saban might yet end up staying, of course, and Dolfans should hope so, because Alabama's ardor accurately reflects a quality coach, despite the unconvincing 15-17 record in his first two pro seasons. He might stay for the personal challenge to succeed in the NFL. He might stay because he feels loyalty or thinks it's right. He might stay because owner Wayne Huizenga convince$ $aban to $tay.

Meantime, the coach cannot blame the media or fans for sincerely wondering whether he will. That's on him.

He began Monday's news conference with a futile preemptive strike by saying this would be about the Dolphins only, ''not about any individual whatever is out there.'' How cute of Nick to believe he could manage the news so neatly. It was a little like President Bush advising assembled White House reporters he would prefer no questions on Iraq, thank you.

Came a question asking Saban directly if he expected to be coach here next year.

''I'm not talking about any of that stuff,'' he huffed. ``And I'd appreciate the courtesy of it not being asked.''

(Courtesy? How about the courtesy of answering a a fair question fairly? How about the courtesy of fulfilling the three remaining years on your contract?)

Came another question persisting whether Saban was willing to entertain an offer from Alabama.

Harvey Greene, the Dolphins' vice president in charge of being a buffer between the media and coach, interrupted the question by admonishing the reporter to not ''hijack'' the news conference.

Came another question, later, asking Saban when he thought it would be appropriate to ask about Alabama's interest.

''You know, I'm not sure,'' he said. ``When is it appropriate for me to have a chance to get home to my wife and talk to her?''

Came an observation that Saban was giving an impression he might consider Alabama's overtures.

''Why would I give you that impression?'' he said. ``That's your impression.''

Came a question noting a report indicating Saban would meet with Alabama officials this week.

SUDDEN ENDING

''I don't know about that,'' he said -- after which the contentious, uncomfortably entertaining news conference quickly was ended.

At one point, Saban had said: ``Seems like something's missing in life.''

He meant the suddenness of a season ending and there being no more practices or games.

But it seems like there's something missing in this Alabama story, too.

A straightforward coach.
 

bamasae

Scout Team
Nov 5, 2006
109
0
0
Lake Martin
Note to Greg: It's your fault Saban is so dubious.

I know it’s disappointing as a “journalist” not to get your way at every turn. It’s important to think that your job and calling puts your thoughts, concerns and questions above the fray, above the masses, above it all. It is your job to get to the bottom of things and, more importantly, scoop everyone.

All you want is the truth right? I mean what’s so hard about that? Just tell the truth and everything will be fine. And then we look at someone like Jim Mora who made some off the cuff statements that more than likely put the final nails in his coffin…but hey, he told the truth, that’s all that matters right?

You see, for every example you give as to why Nick Saban has brought this on himself, I can give you one for why he has no choice but to circumvent your every question. A man who has no contract on his desk to sign, no formal offer, no real substance to base an answer on and he is supposed to give you the cold hard facts before he even knows what he wants to do himself.

Maybe you were asking the wrong questions. Maybe you should have said, “If Alabama gave you an offer for 40 million AND you thought about it and realized Miami might be shallow next year AND you were not sure another offer would ever come you way like this AND you had sat down and talked to your wife to discuss her thoughts AND you took the time to consider every aspect of the job, in the few waking moments that you have that aren’t tied up everyday with the Dolphins, would you take the job at Alabama? Hypothetically of course coach."

No sir, you and your peers would be all over it so fast that Saban wouldn’t even have a chance to mull it over. Not even time to look at the offer or to discuss it with his wife. The Dolphin nation would call for his head on a platter and Huizenga would have no choice but to cut him lose.

It’s called self preservation, it’s called playing your cards right and in this case it’s called “coach-speak.” Cause and effect – The media’s handling of every previous situation is the cause and increasing ambiguity is the effect. Don’t get mad because you are foiled at every turn these days, the media created this monster long ago and now you have to lie in the bed you made…enjoy it, I hope it’s comfortable.
 
Last edited:

bamaga

Hall of Fame
Apr 29, 2002
14,852
10,381
282
JAWJA
this is probably a very interesting statement-

''You know, I'm not sure,'' he said. ``When is it appropriate for me to have a chance to get home to my wife and talk to her?''-Saban
 

Texastigers

Suspended
Oct 30, 2000
204
1
0
Dallas, TX
www.28designs.com
One thing to consider.

Put the shoe on the other foot for one moment. As an LSU fan and having lived through the Saban side show, I cannot tell you how frustrating it is.

For you right now its exciting a new beginning. You win...

For them, its the same feeling every other place he left has. His usual side stepping, his failure to connect to anyone to give them a sense of commitment. Everyone wants to know should we start looking for a new coach, yes no ???

So you might want to cut those Miami people some slack, although they came to our boards with "Ha Ha we stole Nick Saban" threads, I understand their frustration with Nick Saban. Like you all fans want to know hey what is the story, he has dragged everyone through a roller coaster
"I am not going to be the Alabama coach", to "No comment, let me meet with the AD" etc etc.

As a fan of niether team for the most part, it has been a flat out hoot watching the circus. But understand you may be wearing that shoe one day unless Saban changes his stripes all of a sudden and you will be the victim of "Coach Speak" trust me it is a beating...
 

rolltideas

All-SEC
Aug 21, 2003
1,582
0
0
Tusc. AL USA
Vulgar pile of cash? Not really. Now if it was the 6-year, 40 million dollar offer that FOX Soprts Radio went with last night it would be a totally different story. Why would they let something that ridiculous go on-air. 6.6 mil. a year? Gimme a break!
 

rolltideas

All-SEC
Aug 21, 2003
1,582
0
0
Tusc. AL USA
Well TexasTiger at least we have had a lot of coaching letdowns as practice. We're certainly used to it by now. I am sure the "shock" factor will be taken in stride much more so by the Bama nation taking our recent past into consideration.

Is he even our coach yet? People may be getting way in front of themselves.
 

Proxigean Tide

All-SEC
Oct 13, 1999
1,472
0
0
62
Dover, DE
scur·ri·lous (skûr'ə-ləs, skŭr'-)
adj.
Given to the use of vulgar, coarse, or abusive language; foul-mouthed.
Expressed in vulgar, coarse, and abusive language.


This guy needs to work on his vocabulary.
 

skrayper77

All-American
Sep 4, 2003
3,569
329
202
I'm not a football coach, so I don't know what goes on in their heads...


But why exactly are we defending him? Just because we hope he'll be our coach?
 

BamaFan1961

All-SEC
Oct 26, 2005
1,220
0
0
Hayden, Al
But understand you may be wearing that shoe one day unless Saban changes his stripes all of a sudden and you will be the victim of "Coach Speak" trust me it is a beating...
We have been the victim of "coach speak" before (Fran just before he went to aTm). With the way things are now I don't see very many long term commitments of a coach (ie. such as Joe Pa). College football has advanced to a coach will move for the $ and the institution will fire the coach if he has a run of sub-par seasons. There is very little loyalty left on either side. It is business.
 

Proxigean Tide

All-SEC
Oct 13, 1999
1,472
0
0
62
Dover, DE
As a fan of niether team for the most part, it has been a flat out hoot watching the circus. But understand you may be wearing that shoe one day unless Saban changes his stripes all of a sudden and you will be the victim of "Coach Speak" trust me it is a beating...
I appreciate your intelligent, experienced comments and honest sentiments regarding Saban. However, there may be at least one difference with post-NFL HC Saban vs his time at LSU.

I was living in Baton Rouge when Saban was hired. Part of the justification for his then record salary was that he was coveted by NFL teams as a possible future head coach...that he had options and they were big money options.

The "future in the NFL" thing was ever present around Nick Saban and just got more persistant with every college sucess. If he goes to Bama after 2 years in Miami and a .500 record, that (NFL) option should be pretty much closed for him permanently.
 

bmcklv

All-American
Nov 27, 2006
2,290
1
57
Huntsville, Alabama
But understand you may be wearing that shoe one day unless Saban changes his stripes all of a sudden and you will be the victim of "Coach Speak" trust me it is a beating...
We hear you TT. Believe me, we've been through the Coach Speak cycle before with Coach Fraud. But like some others put it on this board. 3 or 4 yrs w/ Saban is better than none. It should right the ship around T-town. And who knows, if shown enough Love and Respect from the fans, he may stay.

Anyway, it's always a pleasure to read your posts, which is more than I can say about a lot of the non-Tiders that come here. RTR and geaux? tigers (except on A-day)
 

LCN

FB | REC Moderator
Sep 29, 2005
14,249
89
67
55
look at pete carroll his nfl record was comparable yet, his name is mentioned with nfl openings.

It also took one hell of a body of work for his name to begin making the rounds again . If CNS comes to Bama and has a comparaple record to CPC then who cares ? It would be well worth it .



RTR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:BigA:
 

moorav

Banned
Dec 6, 2006
1,398
0
0
In regards to Saban leaving, if he wins he is at the MECCA of college football - where would he go back to the pros maybe. I am not so sure that a winning coach leaves Alabama like they do the average schools. Keep in mind he has never been at a program like Alabama's. I don't think anyone would confuse the LSU or Mich State football programs with ALABAMA.

I like LSU FB myself but just not the same league as USCs, NDs, Bamas..etc

I am concerned with him coming not with him leaving, if he dows not win he will leave- If he wins going anywhere would be a step down
 

ATLBAMAFAN

3rd Team
Feb 2, 2005
223
47
47
If he goes to Bama after 2 years in Miami and a .500 record, that (NFL) option should be pretty much closed for him permanently.
I disagree. Should he come to Bama and turn things around he will be just as attractive to the NFL as Pete Carroll or others. The fact is that in Miami he aquired an aging team with salary cap restrictions. This was not going to be a one or two year turnaround. Although it may have been a very different season had the team doctors made a proper prognosis on Drew Brees. That is who Saban wanted, not Culpepper. With Brees at QB, Miami probably would have won 4 or 5 more games and possibly made the playoffs and we wouldn't have even considered him.
 

New Posts

Latest threads