Film Guy Network comment on Bama's lack of practice last week

[BamaMoon]

Does anyone know what we did last year the off week before Georgia?

 

[Cruloc]

I decided to try to get to the bottom of this:

Practice Photos: Alabama hits the field for first workout of bye week

Check out photos, courtesy of Alabama Athletics, from the Crimson Tide's first on-field practice of its first bye week of the 2025 season.

www.on3.com

"" Alabama held its first football practice of its first bye week on Thursday morning. "

https://247sports.com/college/georgia/longformarticle/everything-kirby-smart-said-during-georgias-first-bye-week-254114409/

"Georgia is on bye this week, but the Bulldogs were back at practice on Monday. "

Honestly, I think DeBoer just put his job on the line. It's a huge gamble, if he loses this will become massive news and I don't think he'll have much support left. If he wins, then the legend of being a big game coach will grow. It's a gamble I'm not sure he needed to take though, just give them light practice... avoid the optics.

So they got 3 days of extra film study / practice that we did not.

That's just plain dumb.

DeBoer better hope his boys come out and light Athens up. This is poor management. You're letting the other guy out work you, that's a no no....especially for the amount of money you make. This guy is saying he doesn't take this seriously.

 

[bamaga]

I dont know , I heard an interview with Kirby and he said he gave his players three days off then a heavy lift day , position meetings and gameplan for Bama starting Monday

 

[KrAzY3]

I dont know , I heard an interview with Kirby and he said he gave his players three days off then a heavy lift day , position meetings and gameplan for Bama starting Monday

There could be some inaccuracies, but here's the reporting on that from the 247 article:
" The Bulldogs' bye week started Monday with Georgia giving some of its higher-snap guys from the Tennessee game a little bit of a breather, while getting some extra work for younger guys down the depth chart. Now, the Georgia will return to practice the rest of the week as if it's a normal practice week."

So, certainly a lighter practice and doesn't sound like everyone was participating, but it was practice according to the report.

Edit: But to be clear the main issue is the optics of it and just general lack of discipline. Players were reportedly there on Monday for Georgia. They were not reportedly there until Thursday for Alabama. Even if just going through the motions, or doing what Kirby did and work the backups harder, it just begs the question of: "Did you have someplace more important to be?". Just not a good look and may be something can bridge this gap, I'd welcome it but I did my homework and that's what I got.

 

[TideMan09]

Bottom line is just win, if you dont, Deboer's time at Bama will be a short one..

 

[mlh]

Well, as they say, no matter how thin you slice it, there are always two sides to the bread. The fact of the matter is, we don't know what the atmosphere is like in the football complex. And we don't know if there was extra film study or position meetings in lieu of practice.

If we come out with some intensity and play hard and look prepared like we have the last two weeks, then no foul - even if we lose in a close game.

But if we come out flat and look unprepared like we did against FSU, this will be a huge issue. Especially if we get beat soundly.

 

[KrAzY3]

Well, as they say, no matter how thin you slice it, there are always two sides to the bread. The fact of the matter is, we don't know what the atmosphere is like in the football complex. And we don't know if there was extra film study or position meetings in lieu of practice.

Ultimately success is what matters. I can say they needed to do this, or need to do that, but ultimately success is the goal.

If Alabama wins @ Georgia the narrative will totally flip. Instead of DeBoer being on the hot seat it will be talking about how he owns Kirby. All will be forgiven, for a little while at least.

 

[TiderJack]

Does anyone know what we did last year the off week before Georgia?

We did what we did this year in 2024 also and we won the game. And if any of you think they were not doing S&C and watching film during this time you would be wrong.

Alabama's bye week was in late September 2024, leading up to their game against Georgia on September 28. While the practice schedule for that week isn't publicly available due to the closed nature of bye week practices for reporters, their first practice was held on Thursday, September 19, where players were in "shells" (half pads) at the Thomas-Drew Practice Fields for about an hour and a half. The team then continued preparations for their SEC opener against the Bulldogs

 

[Power Eye]

There could be some inaccuracies, but here's the reporting on that from the 247 article:
" The Bulldogs' bye week started Monday with Georgia giving some of its higher-snap guys from the Tennessee game a little bit of a breather, while getting some extra work for younger guys down the depth chart. Now, the Georgia will return to practice the rest of the week as if it's a normal practice week."

So, certainly a lighter practice and doesn't sound like everyone was participating, but it was practice according to the report.

Edit: But to be clear the main issue is the optics of it and just general lack of discipline. Players were reportedly there on Monday for Georgia. They were not reportedly there until Thursday for Alabama. Even if just going through the motions, or doing what Kirby did and work the backups harder, it just begs the question of: "Did you have someplace more important to be?". Just not a good look and may be something can bridge this gap, I'd welcome it but I did my homework and that's what I got.

What's interesting is that there really weren't any optics of it until the Film Guy, who is a UGA fan, brought it up a week later. I listen to a fair amount of Alabama podcasts and no one questioned it or even mentioned the fact that the players didn't practice until Thursday. So only once someone, who is a UGA fan, mentions it do we make a big deal of it. I don't think it's a big deal at all, and I'm sure they were doing film study and positional meetings, but I don't know that.

 

[bamaga]

There could be some inaccuracies, but here's the reporting on that from the 247 article:
" The Bulldogs' bye week started Monday with Georgia giving some of its higher-snap guys from the Tennessee game a little bit of a breather, while getting some extra work for younger guys down the depth chart. Now, the Georgia will return to practice the rest of the week as if it's a normal practice week."

So, certainly a lighter practice and doesn't sound like everyone was participating, but it was practice according to the report.

Edit: But to be clear the main issue is the optics of it and just general lack of discipline. Players were reportedly there on Monday for Georgia. They were not reportedly there until Thursday for Alabama. Even if just going through the motions, or doing what Kirby did and work the backups harder, it just begs the question of: "Did you have someplace more important to be?". Just not a good look and may be something can bridge this gap, I'd welcome it but I did my homework and that's what I got.

What I wrote wasnt an article , a reporter or hearsay. It was the answer Kirby Smart gave to Randy McMichael when asked on 92.9 The Game in Atlanta

 

[BamaMoon]

We did what we did this year in 2024 also and we won the game. And if any of you think they were not doing S&C and watching film during this time you would be wrong.

Alabama's bye week was in late September 2024, leading up to their game against Georgia on September 28. While the practice schedule for that week isn't publicly available due to the closed nature of bye week practices for reporters, their first practice was held on Thursday, September 19, where players were in "shells" (half pads) at the Thomas-Drew Practice Fields for about an hour and a half. The team then continued preparations for their SEC opener against the Bulldogs

What's interesting is that there really weren't any optics of it until the Film Guy, who is a UGA fan, brought it up a week later. I listen to a fair amount of Alabama podcasts and no one questioned it or even mentioned the fact that the players didn't practice until Thursday. So only once someone, who is a UGA fan, mentions it do we make a big deal of it. I don't think it's a big deal at all, and I'm sure they were doing film study and positional meetings, but I don't know that.

What I thought.

 

[AlistarWills]

Players can’t just take off and do whatever because of “school”. I think we are overlooking having cut ups assigned to study, team led work. Some of yall acting like the entire athletic complex took off to Vegas for 4 days and said to heck with football and personally I feel it’s that way cause DeBoer isn’t Nick Saban and you don’t like him for it.

 

[dtgreg]

Kirby can't give them time off due to all the speeding when they have free time.

Why the blue font?