I have to say that your statement is one of the most mind boggling I have ever read . It's more like Cecil , Kirk , 100 others and then Scott Moore . Now , I feel badly for ever having anything to do with the existence of his "career" .
Anyone who allows acquaintances to quote their private conversations or , submit summaries of them on a public board has lost 100% of whatever credibility they may have once had . Scott has allowed such to happen every day since the search began .
Cecil & Kirk know more than any other members of the media . Other than Finebaum , nobody else is even on the same planet . One of the reasons is that they don't burn sources by sharing insider info with aquaintances or allow summaries of confidential information to be posted on public sports boards .
Just remember that the ones who know what's up , are not and will not be spilling their info for public posting - ever . As soon as they did , their sources would be finished with them - forever .
You are entitled to feel how you feel, however "confidential sources" do not always share information meaning for it to be kept in confidence.
I know Scott...and I also know some of the same people he knows...only he knows them on a more personal basis. If Scott is adamant that something will happen, I would bank on it...but sometimes a situation is fluid and subject to changing. If he is guilty of anything, it is the typical desire that media types have to be the first with the scoop. That is how Rich Rod ended up on the front page of the Bham News as Alabama's new coach...and how Dewey defeated Truman.
One issue that Scott and I and others who know a few people are dealing with now, is that Saban plays things much closer to the vest than others did. Most of my AD contacts are gone now, and the BOT folks are not as "in the loop" as they once were.
There are always varying degrees of certainty and things don't always play out. I was 80% sure that Tubs was gone to Arkansas - because of connections I have with the Barn BOT...but it turned into a game of chicken and neither one would flinch...now his Coordinators are gone in large part because of it.
I guess calling him a hack is not unfair. The same thing can be said about anyone who reports in secondary media format - and increasingly it is the case with mainstream media as they try to keep up with the "hacks" who are breaking news while they are verifying sources.
In the long run, too many misses will kill credibility, but so will being presented as an "unbiased reporter" covering the Keller lawsuit, while having had him as a cosigner to a personal loan...and so will spending 3 years defending your buddy Logan Young while Bama gets hammered because of his activities. I don't know that Moore has struck out as many times as he has hit home runs, but I know about Cecil and Kirk. I still consider them generally reliable, but I trust Scott if they butt heads...and the track record supports that stance.
As for Finebaum...he is connected, but he is the ultimate hack and promoter of disinformation to suit his own purposes. Scott has no purpose other than wanting a scoop.