McElroy scores Jets only pre-season TD

[Proxigean Tide]

He won't be because their paying the other guys too much for them to sit, but in terms of effectiveness I'm not sure Greg
isn't more of a prototypical NFL QB than both Sanchez or Tebow.

Alasippi

I really like your posts. I think Greg may very well be more of a QB than his two competitors. RTR.

 

[DiamondDust]

I could not disagree more strongly.

Jacksonville - New owner that would have drafted him and appreciated his worth, he is from the area, he would be the starter, more tolerant of religion, would have fans and press on his side. Did I mention that he would be in Florida?

New York - Foreign to him and not tolerant of preaching religious views, will not start, if he does press and fan base will be divided, crude head coach, locker room issues.

Tebow chose Broadway over football imo and will soon learn that his star power is related to Tebow Time. He will either be on the bench or under enormous scrutiny by his own fans if he starts. He can't grow in New York, thus he made a football career ending blunder.

Just his presence in Jacksonville would have created tremendous buzz for the team and fans. I don;t think his magic will have any effect in New York. Will be just another player.

He wouldn't have grown as a football player in Jacksonville, either. The "buzz" would have quickly worn off in Jacksonville when people remembered the rest of the team + the franchise overall is horrible.

 

[exiledNms]

<snip> I still don't understand his reasoning, unless it was an ego thing.

Wait, you're suggesting that St. Tim has an ego? Shame on you. Tebow for 5 minutes while repeating "Pope Urban & St. Tim" over & over!

 

[Alasippi]

Alasippi

I really like your posts. I think Greg may very well be more of a QB than his two competitors. RTR.

If I was the Jets and had a big game to play I'd feel more confident in Greg than the other two. They have a lot of hype behind them and you have to respect Tebow as an athlete but I just don't think Sanchez or Tebow as quarterbacks can lead the Jets to the next level.

 

[CapstoneTider]

He wouldn't have grown as a football player in Jacksonville, either. The "buzz" would have quickly worn off in Jacksonville when people remembered the rest of the team + the franchise overall is horrible.

So you basically think he will fail just about anywhere, correct? It that is true, I can understand you position a little better lol.

 

[Catfish]

Here's a video of the TD. You have sit through a 30 second ad.

[video]http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-game-highlights/0ap2000000056573/Ganaway-TD-for-Jets[/video]

 

[DiamondDust]

So you basically think he will fail just about anywhere, correct? It that is true, I can understand you position a little better lol.

Well, I definitely think he'll fail as a player with the Jets because... well... they're the Jets. They have an offensive coordinator who is still running the Wildcat, even though the rest of the league has learned how to defend it. My view on Jacksonville has already been stated. As for other teams, I have to say... yeah... he'd be an average at best quarterback... if that.

 

[bamaga]

He should be the Jets starting QB.

There are a lot of Jets fans that feel this way

 

[bamaga]

I'm a Greg fan, hope he continues to improve.

Actually, I think he has regressed. the Jets offense is a disaster, Schotty was average at best OC, Sparano is a power football OC in a league built for the pass.