I'm guessing we're getting out the rose-colored glasses. I always thought Watts was an over-hyped QB.
Oh and for those saying he didn't cost us games, I'm assuming you forgot the Oklahoma backward fling in 2002. Now to be fair, Watts didn't blow that game himself, but the 1994 Barker I keep hearing him compared to would have taken it down and punched it in.
I also remember the QB controversy. Nobody seems to want to point out the reason we had a controversy was because neither QB (Zow or Watts) was overly spectacular. Most QB controversies involve highly talented folks (Simms-Applewhite, Tebow-Leake)....ours involved which guy was going to do less to beat us rather than who was going to do more to beat the other team.
I'm sure Watts is a nice enough fella just like I'm sure Zow is. But the platooning in game really only worked in 1999 - and that had more to do with Samuels and Alexander than with either QB.