250 years ago today, General Gage and Washington exchange insults the eighteenth century way, with politely worded letters.
It seems some Britiah prisoners in American hands had been put to work to earn their keep. On the British side, American officers and enlisted men were being housed together, in violation of the laws of war, which required offices and enlisted men to be kept separately. Gage said he does not count American officers as officers.
Here is their exchange:
From Lieutenant General Thomas Gage
Boston 13th August 1775.
Sir
To the Glory of Civilized Nations, humanity and War have been compatible; and Compassion to the subdued, is become almost a general system. ...
Your Prisoners, … have hitherto been treated with care and kindness, and more comfortably lodged then the King’s Troops … [but as for segregating officers,]
I Acknowledge no Rank that is not derived from the King. …
There are of the King’s faithfull Subjects, taken sometime since by the Rebels, labouring like Negro Slaves, to gain their daily Subsistence, or reduced to the Wretched Alternative, to perish by famine, or take Arms against their King and Country. …
Those under whose usurped Authority you Act, … dare to call severity retaliation, … I trust that British Soldiers Asserting the rights of the State, the Laws of the Land, the being of the Constitution, will meet all Events with becoming fortitude. …
I am, Sir,
Your most Obedient humble Servant
Thos Gage
To Lieutenant General Thomas Gage
Head Quarters Cambridge Augt 19th 1775.
Sir
… I remonstrated with you, on the unworthy Treatment shewn to the Officers, and Citizens of America, whom the Fortune of War, Chance, or a mistaken Confidence had thrown into your Hands. … whether our virtuous Citizens whom the Hand of Tyranny has forced into Arms, to defend their Wives, their Children, & their Property; or … Whether t
he Authority under which I act is usurp’d, or founded on the genuine Principles of Liberty, were altogether foreign to my Subject. I purposely avoided all political Disquisition; nor shall I now avail myself of those Advantages, which
the sacred Cause of my Country, of Liberty, and human Nature give me over you. Much less shall I stoop to Retort, & Invective. But the Intelligence, you say, you have received from our Army requires a Reply. I have taken Time, Sir, to make a strict Inquiry, and find it has not the least Foundation in Truth. Not only your Officers, and Soldiers have been treated with a Tenderness due to Fellow Citizens, & Brethren; but even those execrable Parricides, whose Counsels & Aid have deluged their Country with Blood, have been protected from the Fury of a justly enraged People. Far from compelling, or even permitting their Assistance, I am embarassed with the Numbers who crowd to our Camp animated with the purest Principles of Virtue, & Love of their Country…
You affect, Sir, to despise all Rank not derived from the same Source with your own. I cannot conceive any more honourable, than that which flows from the uncorrupted Choice of a brave and free Poeple—The purest Source & original Fountain of all Power. …
Those who influence the Councils of America, and all the other Inhabitants of these united Colonies, at the Hazard of their Lives, are resolved to
hand down to Posterity those just & invaluable Privileges which they received from their Ancestors.
I shall now, Sir, close my Correspondence with you, perhaps forever. If your Officers who are our Prisoners receive a Treatment from me, different from what I wish’d to shew them, they, & you, will remember the Occasion of it.
I am Sir, Your very Hbble Servant
Go: Washington
In other words, Washington was telling Gage that British officers in American hands would receive the same treatment that American officers in British hands did, so be careful what you do.
It is ironic that the Americans, which became the classless society, was taking to task the British, the class-conscious society, for holding officers and enlisted men together.