The Good, The Bad and The Ugly…. Badger style:

[Bama Lee]

The Good- Ty Simpson is balling. Nice to see Ryan Williams get his mojo back (might be more comfortable out wide instead of in slot). OL showed improvemen. The defense came to play. Bray Hubbard deserves a special shout out… wow!

The Bad- Ryan Williams drops…. What’s up with that? and a few others. They need to work on the jugs machine

The Ugly- what’s up with all the bad calls by refs? Mystery calls galore

 

[BamaBoySince89]

Good: Ty Simpson being very efficient, very decisive with his reads.

Bad: Penalty leading to a KO return TD for Wisconsin

Ugly: I still think the drops are a problem

 

[WMack4Bama]

Good: Ty is in firm command of this offense. Wommack has quietly been masterful the past two weeks. London Simmons has taken full advantage of his opportunity. Our backup defenders are HUNGRY.

Bad: How the offense sputtered and died after the Williams TD drop. That's where Saban would've been losing his mind and yelling at everyone within an earshot.

Ugly: The Williams TD drop. He actually double caught a pass earlier in the game. He's gotta attack the ball and not let it get up on him.

 

[bamadwain]

Good- The offense played real well, Defense definitely getting better
Bad- The drops and not being able to run the ball better
Ugly- Still no KD team has been penalized less than the opposing team

 

[Bama Lee]

Good: Ty Simpson being very efficient, very decisive with his reads.

Bad: Penalty leading to a KO return TD for Wisconsin

Ugly: I still think the drops are a problem

Did anyone see the penalty? I kept rewinding and never saw it. But that was true on several of those calls

 

[Bama Lee]

Good- The offense played real well, Defense definitely getting better
Bad- The drops and not being able to run the ball better
Ugly- Still no KD team has been penalized less than the opposing team

They had 65 yards we had 57

 

[bamadwain]

They had 65 yards we had 57

But we still had more penalties

 

[arthurdawg]

The Good- Ty Simpson is balling. Nice to see Ryan Williams get his mojo back (might be more comfortable out wide instead of in slot). OL showed improvemen. The defense came to play. Bray Hubbard deserves a special shout out… wow!

The Bad- Ryan Williams drops…. What’s up with that? and a few others. They need to work on the jugs machine

The Ugly- what’s up with all the bad calls by refs? Mystery calls galore

Scary thing (for opponents) is that Ty was 24-29 with a few dropsies... He is turning out to be a machine.

Honestly... FSU numbers would have looked pretty durned good if there hadn't been right at 8 dropped balls that were solidly catchable.


The Good: All of It

The Bad: Still need to work on running game (Wiscy played us tough and sold out) and DL depth, although they did well today. These aren't really bads though...

The Ugly: Nothing

 

[OconeeTide]

Good: Ty good lord, DL pressure, Bernard
Bad: penalties, ST
Ugly: drops, Questionable officiating on both sides.

 

[arthurdawg]

Good: Ty is in firm command of this offense. Wommack has quietly been masterful the past two weeks. London Simmons has taken full advantage of his opportunity. Our backup defenders are HUNGRY.

Bad: How the offense sputtered and died after the Williams TD drop. That's where Saban would've been losing his mind and yelling at everyone within an earshot.

Ugly: The Williams TD drop. He actually double caught a pass earlier in the game. He's gotta attack the ball and not let it get up on him.

London was getting some mentions, glad we have at least one guy who look solid for next year and as a backup this year. It has been too long since we had DUDES on the DL. We need to dude up this year.

 

[rolltide_21]

Good- Passing game
Bad- 3rd Down Offense
Ugly- LTO injury

 

[TideEngineer08]

Good: Ty Simpson and these WRs are becoming lethal. Defense is really coming around. Hubbard and Simmons really stood out today. Kicker and Punter look solid.

Bad: OL is struggling. Blitz pickups by the backs are sporadic at best. I’m not sure how much Jam’s return is going to help but we will see soon, hopefully. The WR drops have to get cleaned up.

Ugly: more DL injuries. Hopefully Overton’s is minor. And perhaps in a separate even uglier category: refs. This particular crew is horrible and has been for four years now. Several phantom calls today.

 

[CB4]

Good: Ty’s execution and running the offense.

Bad: lack of a physical OL in run game and on the defensive front. Conference games are won at the LOS. We have to establish some balance in run game.

Ugly: lack of concentration by WRs late in game. It is a 60 minute game. Play like it.

 

[Saban4Ever]

Anyone know of James Smith and LT Overtons injuries?
Bama played great!
Need to cut down on penalties and also run the ball better in SEC play.

 

[Bluegrasstide]

The Good: Got the W, loved the flea flicker/screen
The Bad: Run the dad gum ball some, penalties
The Ugly: The gorge in the middle of our kick coverage

 

[RammerJammer14]

The Good: Ty Simpson is on fire

The Bad: What is with these drops of almost perfect passes?

The Ugly: Another game in the long streak of committing more penalties than our opponents. 16 games and counting now.

 

[Ledsteplin]

The Good: Simpson joined Mac Jones as only 2 QBs in school history to complete at least 80% of his passes and throw for 3 TDs in consecutive games! The Defense was stout.

The Bad: Some drops looked bad. Refs calls.

The Ugly: All that orange in the following game.

 

[arthurdawg]

Ty is 41/46 last two games... 89%...

 

[DzynKingRTR]

Ty is 41/46 last two games... 89%...

bench him

 

[JustNeedMe81]

Good: Ty is in firm command of this offense. Wommack has quietly been masterful the past two weeks. London Simmons has taken full advantage of his opportunity. Our backup defenders are HUNGRY.

Bad: How the offense sputtered and died after the Williams TD drop. That's where Saban would've been losing his mind and yelling at everyone within an earshot.

Ugly: The Williams TD drop. He actually double caught a pass earlier in the game. He's gotta attack the ball and not let it get up on him.

I think you nailed it. No reason for me to make a post because you covered all of my concerns.