Question: What is the rule re:offside when three men in motion at the snap?

[Power Eye]

The only justifiable defense of the ref's on that call is that they thought Turner touched the left tackle before the snap, which he didn't though it was close.. Otherwise, that was a totally botched call.

 

[NoNC4Tubs]

Just chalk it up to the long list of missed calls both ways.

As I've said in other threads, I think the crew was incompetent, but not biased.

And why the SEC can't get better officiating, I don't understand.

The SEC is arguably the premiere conference in CFB. THAT is a question that I wish they would answer...

 

[NoNC4Tubs]

BTW - Had to find if for myself and they apparently did get the replay review correct on the pick 6.View attachment 38596

What review?!?

Autrey and his clown crew were heading for the tunnel instead of even explaining it to....everyone watching.

 

[Isaiah 63:1]

The only justifiable defense of the ref's on that call is that they thought Turner touched the left tackle before the snap...

...which would have been a dead-ball foul and would have stopped the play. There is no justifiable defense of the refs on this play, just as there isn't on many other bad calls and no calls that day that hurt both teams...

 

[Krymsonman]

Auburn also had to many men in the backfield. With 3 in motion plus the qb and rb , that makes 5

Video

Thanks for the video look. I was wanting to see another look. CBS sure didn't show it. Clearly shows three guys in motion at the snap. That should have been a pretty easy call for a competent officiating crew, but we got Barney and his gang. Wait, that's an insult to Barney Fife. Autry is way worse than that.

 

[Krymsonman]

Just chalk it up to the long list of missed calls both ways.

As I've said in other threads, I think the crew was incompetent, but not biased.

And why the SEC can't get better officiating, I don't understand.

I don't know. With that Autry crew, I think biased is a good word. Maybe not particularly against BAMA, (but I think so), but they sure do lean to the home team. Once they missed that early facemask, it seemed every crucial went to Auburn. Gotta keep the crowd off their back. How else could they botch that call a couple of years ago in the Auburn /Arky game. They got suspended then and should have stayed suspended.

 

[Snuffy Smith]

What review?!?

Autrey and his clown crew were heading for the tunnel instead of even explaining it to....everyone watching.

Yeah - my assumption is that it was reviewed & overturned by someone in B’ham.

 

[Windsortide]

True, but that does not excuse Alabama's jump. Both teams should have been flagged.

That is exactly what the problem was with the call. Just like when the block in the back was called instead of the face mask. Both penalties needed to be flagged.

 

[Windsortide]

I am sure the SEC has sent out some letters to the AD’s of each programs for the egregious calls and non calls, blown reviews, etc…

 

[editder]

I’m just wondering why that penalty hound Gary Danielson didn’t harp on it for the rest of the game.

 

[editder]

We were offsides and they had multiple players in motion illegally.

The officials last night were awful…both ways.

Its beyond comprehension that officials at this level can be so bad.

Why should Bama have been flagged? Maybe the fact that 3 players were in motion is what drew them offsides.

 

[B1GTide]

Why should Bama have been flagged? Maybe the fact that 3 players were in motion is what drew them offsides.

You cannot be legally drawn offsides by a player who is allowed to move. All 3 Auburn players in motion were players who were allowed to go into motion.

 

[editder]

You cannot be legally drawn offsides by a player who is allowed to move. All 3 Auburn players in motion were players who were allowed to go into motion.

Got it. Thanks. I guess they just can’t be moving at the snap.

 

[B1GTide]

Got it. Thanks. I guess they just can’t be moving at the snap.

Exactly

 

[day-day]

The same Gary Danielson that said Milroe could step over the LoS, step back behind it, and throw a legal forward pass. And he was an NFL QB ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Gary Danielson said it looked like Milroe went over the line and it would be a penalty. The other announcer was calling play-by-play and mentioned Milroe might get back behind before making the throw giving the impression that he thought a throw would be legal.

Start at about 2:05:08 if the video doesn't start there already:

 

[Jay Hughes]

BTW - Had to find if for myself and they apparently did get the replay review correct on the pick 6.View attachment 38596

Was his foot down or was it in the air in motion? Can’t say unless you watch in slow motion and see him plant his foot. Just saying

 

[day-day]

Was his foot down or was it in the air in motion? Can’t say unless you watch in slow motion and see him plant his foot. Just saying

Good point; photos don't always tell the whole story. The video shows the foot goes down on top of the sideline.

 

[B1GTide]

Good point; photos don't always tell the whole story. The video shows the foot goes down on top of the sideline.

I remember in real time thinking that he stepped out there, but wasn't sure.

 

[Revrph79]

Autry was at the bottom of the pile when the players were fighting during the last kick off. The referees paid for letting the game get out of hand for several got knocked down in the scrum.

 

[NoNC4Tubs]

Yeah - my assumption is that it was reviewed & overturned by someone in B’ham.

Possibly, but Autrey was probably in the tunnel before that determination was made...