BET, do you really think we would take a JUCO safety? We already have Nick Perry, and Jarrick Williams seems to be a pretty safe bet for this class at safety. I know they won't contribute for a few more years, but I think we have plenty of depth at safety. Woodall does graduate after this year, but Green seems to have stepped up to take one safety spot, and there are still guys like BJ Scott, Mark Barron AND Rod Woodson competing for the other spot. Usually JUCO guys come in to fill a hole, like Carpenter, and I don't really believe we have a hole at Safety.
I think you make a good argument, and I think you have a point to an extent. I do not think safety is necessarily a major need right now, and that certainly has to be a strike against Hamilton.
On the other hand, though, at the free safety position we really have no one else besides Robby Green right now. Scott should stay at corner, while Barron and Woodson are more strong safety types. Maybe the staff just does not feel comfortable of perhaps putting a true freshman in that role, and in any event Green is not a proven commodity just yet in his own right. Furthermore, it really helps Hamilton's case that he will enroll in December and get a big jumpstart on the 2010 class guys like Williams and Perry. Moreover, while we really don't have a huge need at safety, with that in mind we really don't have any huge needs anywhere, honestly. With as much talent as we've got in the past two classes, it's pretty much all gravy and taking the best player available at this point.
Like I said, I think you have a good argument, and you might be right. We might eventually cool on Hamilton for that reason, but by the same token we might think a JUCO safety can give us some legitimate value. Besides, perhaps the staff feels that Hamilton is one of those guys you cannot really pass on. We'll see how it plays out.