I think the BEST PROOF of Boise's lack of ability to compete with the big dogs is what has happened to their coaches when they went to other jobs that actually required them to play more than one decent team per year.
Houston Nutt
Dirk Koetter
Dan Hawkins
None of them has even come close to an unbeaten season when he had to play decent teams. Koetter handed off a ten-win team to Hawkins, who then had three double-digit win teams in five years. Then came Petersen, who has had double digit wins every year.
According to Sorenson, consider their SOS the last ten years:
2001 - 91st
2002 - 112th
2003 - 95th
2004 - 73rd
2005 - 93rd
2006 - 88th
2007 - 112th
2008 - 93rd
2009 - 93rd
Now let's look at just a few of those games for a comparison and we'll see that the Boise haters are dead on right.
2001 - they play South Carolina ON THE ROAD and get creamed, 32-13. This same SCe team edges a 7-5 Alabama team by one point and then beats Ohio State in the Outback Bowl.
2002 - they lost to Arkansas ON THE ROAD by a score of 41-14. This same Arkansas team lost to a probation riddled Alabama team by a EIGHTEEN POINTS.
2003 - again they play one DECENT team ON THE ROAD, Oregon State - and they LOSE, 26-24.
2004 - they again get all their tough teams (both of them) at HOME and go undefeated. Then they go ON THE ROAD and lose the bowl game to Louisville by four points.
2005 - they finally decide to play two decent foes back-to-back and one the road.....and they LOSE both of them, 45-14 to Georgia and by 3 to Oregon State. They play two other decent teams - Fresno State and BC on the road - and lose BOTH of them.
(Anyone who cannot see a pattern now is blind. They DO NOT play tough road games except in the opener - and they lose every time they do).
2006 - they kill Oregon State....at HOME. They play Wyoming on the road (6-6) and only win by a TD. Of course, they beat Oklahoma with a month to prepare..
2007 - they lose ON THE ROAD to a TERRIBLE (4-9) Washington team, and lose ON THE ROAD to a 12-1 Hawaii team. Oh and who beat Hawaii you remember? Georgia smoked them, 41-10.
(And folks wonder why SEC fans are NOT impressed with these clowns)
2008 - sure enough they lose another road game to TCU by one point.
Has anybody noticed a pattern? OK, so they went to Mississippi and beat a mediocre Southern Miss team....the same Southern Miss team that gave up 27 points to Auburn's pathetic 2008 offense and got killed by the Tigers. So sure Boise beat USM that year. So did Auburn, Marshall, UTEP, Rice, and Memphis before they recovered but not enough to save Jeff Bower.