Thing is, our troubles in JHS predate Saban, so I honestly don't know what kind of correlation we can find. Granted - the Saban teams have been the best or among the best year-in and year-out, certainly better than the Curry or Dubious years, but it makes no sense.
1989 - we're #2 in the nation and weren't really that good (we played above our heads plus the SEC had a bit of a down year beyond the Top 3)...and we lose our shot at a title
1993 - we're leading most of the game and collapse late, Barker goes out with an injury.
1995 - lost that one largely because officials called Curtis Brown's TD out of bounds.
1997 - Ed Scissum
We could have won at a minimum ALL of those last 3 - but weird things.
==========================
But as I've noted for years, there's a psychological component to the whole thing: Auburn will never be able to match Alabama's history on the field. Never, it can never happen. It's too long and too incredible. This creates two kinds of Auburn fans:
1) guys like our own AUDub (and I've met many others), who admit this but live in the now and root for their team like mad, don't diss the reality and are classy. These are the ones we mistreat from time to time (not so much here) that disgust me more at OUR fans than theirs.
2) the other 90%, who are so livid with rage at denying that reality that they make up the dumbest arguments you've ever heard to try and deny it:
- "national championships are popularity contests, they don't really exist"
- "Most Alabama fans never attended so much as one class there"
- "Bama cheats, pays referees, pays players, and the SEC offices are in Birmingham"
- "nearly every Bryant assistant who became a head coach got their teams put on probation (Sherrill, Pell, Ford, Stallings), they learned to cheat from the Master Cheater" (they always exclude former Bryant assistant Pat Dye, but I'm sure that's an honest oversight)
And for Group 2, their life consists of little victories that assuage the inferiority complex like:
- "we'll show them Bama snobs! We gonna make them come play in our sandbox!"
- "let me write this Bleacher Report showing you how Alabama's titles are mostly mythical"
- "I hope Alabama loses in the playoffs"
That inferiority complex trickles down or in this case. It permeates everyone in a position of power at that school from Bobby Lowder to David Housel to Pat Dye to Jay Jacobs to the Cam Newton bagman. But they are MORE UNITED than we are on game day because, in essence, theirs is a one-game season. Let's face it, how often does Auburn go into the Iron Bowl still in the running for the national championship, which now even according to their raging way of viewing, they have to admit exists? They're usually eliminated by October 10, sometimes by September 25. The ONE THING that unites them is beating Alabama.
We don't sink that much emotion into that one particular game - except one time - 2010.
Oh yeah, and what happened in 2010?
Alabama was out of the national title hunt and had only one potential achievement left.
Auburn was in the national title hunt, and we could take them out.
That's why that was the ONE TIME the BDS crowd was so into an Iron Bowl.
Yeah, it's just a theory and I'm no shrink...but I'd say 2010 serves as further evidence given the polar opposite approaches of everything, too.